The two sources no second troy and troy are both based on iliad and other greek myths about the trojan war the major story line is the same in both materials, with subtle changes tailoring to the audience and purpose of the material. Smellin' of troy what follows is a partial list of discrepancies between troy the big-budget hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history. The greeks won the war, and the trojan horse let them win the iliad vs troy agamemnon brought the kings together for war agamemnon did not do this in the book. This essay comparison of troy and the there are obvious deviations from the book such as the length of the trojan war, and the absence of celestial participation .
In the iliad, many gods are physically involved in the war, fighting alongside the mortal humans, however in troy, the gods are not even shown to exist, they are just the subject of prayer and praises, with the most tangible example being a statue of apollo. Essay on comparison of troy and the iliad obvious deviations from the book such as the length of the trojan war, and the absence of celestial participation in the . Troy (2004) quotes on imdb: memorable quotes and exchanges from movies, tv series and more.
The plot of the book and the film has a very big difference especially on its coverage and focus - comparison of iliad book and troy film introduction the coverage of the film starts all the way from why the trojan-greeks conflict started up to the death of achilles and the fall of troy. Max frankovits professor kotch troy & the trojan war 24 october 2016 fort apache and the iliad: comparison essay in the movie fort apache, directed by john ford, and the iliad, written by homer, the modern movie fort apache is almost identical to the epic the iliad, in its storyline and characterization. But, at a run-time of nearly three hours, troy is the most thorough screen adaptation of the story of the trojan war the film's credits make clear that troy was 'inspired by' homer's the iliad . What's the difference between the iliad the book and troy the movie troy book vs movie warning achilles that if he participates in the trojan war he is .
Troy (the movie) essays: over 180,000 troy (the movie) essays, troy (the movie) term papers, troy (the movie) research paper, book reports 184 990 essays, term and research papers available for unlimited access. The adaptaters of the lord of the rings put a lot of effort to include everyone's favourite bits from the book how well does the movie troy do by this criterion first off, let me try to remember the story of the trojan war. In the iliad the war took 10 years (quote: already have nine years of great zeus gone by), whereas in the film troy it only took 17 daysin the iliad, patroclus was not the cousin of achilles, only a friend. The trojan war, fought between greeks and the defenders of the city of troy in anatolia sometime in the late bronze age, has grabbed the imagination.
Troy vs the iliad tuesday, 16 october 2012 some historians debate that the trojan war is a myth while others believe that homer's iliad is truely based on the . This post was occasioned by a query on the pendraken forum concerning a size comparison of the ancient ranges of pendraken and magister militum, both of which i’m using for my trojan war work having them readily available i ran up a quick picture:. Troy: differences between the movie and the mythos main differences between the original greek myth and the film according to the myths, zeus, athena, apollo, hera, aphrodite and poseidon all played active parts in the trojan war. In greek mythology, hector, the oldest child of king priam and hecuba, was the presumed heir to the throne of troy this devoted husband of andromache and father of astyanax was the greatest trojan hero of the trojan war, the main defender of troy, and a favorite of apollo hector in the illiad as .
Comparison of book trojan war to movie troy troy was considered a mythical city until archeologist heinrich schliemann discovered the remains of the city in 1871 archeological digs have brought up many truths about the history of troy, and about the trojan war, which supposedly occurred arou. In comparing the blockbuster movie troy to secondary sources found o the internet and in various texts, there are many significant differences in the portrayal of odysseus and his involvement in trojan warin the movie, the first we see of odysseus is . Black ships before troy: the story of the iliad is a novel for children written by rosemary sutcliff, illustrated by alan lee, and published (posthumously) by frances lincoln in 1993 partly based on the iliad , the book retells the story of the trojan war , beginning with the birth of paris to the building of the trojan horse .